What would you pay for these guns?-Quiz of sorts.

[Vikram]

Dear members, I found these guns for sale and the commonality is that they are all boxlock SXSs,all from decent makers.Please place a price you think is appropriate for each gun by its number.Ex: 1. $XXXX

I will reveal the actual prices asked by the sellers at the end.You may find this exercise interesting.Thank you for participating. The winner gets to drink all the best bitters the local pub has to offer.

1.






2.






3.





4.







5.






Best-
Vikram

[jonahpach]

Hey Vikram here's my quote..
1. $ 600
2. $ 400
3. $ 400
4. $ 700
5. $ 500

jonah

[winnie_the_pooh]

My estimate,

1.Excellent condition saar.Presented by the Viceroy to the Maharaja of .....(take your pick and it shall be stamped on the gun). NIB condition saar. Only 3.5 lakhs

2.William Evans saar.Engraved hai saar.Stock thoda theek karna pada(replaced at about 2500-5000/- cost to the dealer). 1.5 lakhs

3.NIB 2.5 lakhs.Aisi Indian maien aur nahin hai

4.Shall be sold after slapping on a cheapo recoil pad for 3lakhs (more engraving )

5. Brand New.Imported in 2009. 4 lakhs

[nagarifle]

i would say

1/2 500quid
2/1 790 quid
3\ 1500 quid
4/3 400 quid
5/5500 quid

[sa_ali]

too novice to comment on the price, but the stock of no 2 is interesting.
Forgive me for being novice, why that shape, it looks as if custom made for that curve.

But given the choice to buy, i would buy them in following order

5.
1.
4.
3.
2.

But no clue on the Price.

[vishosingh]

no. 2 looks like tiger pataudi's shotgun

[herb]

I am assuming in the range of $2000-$6000.

Interesting stock on gun number 2 (William Evans), looks like cast for a right hand shooter with dominant left eye.

Herb

[Vikram]

Right, gentlemen, what sparked this post was when I saw the price the seller was asking for gun number4.It surprised me a lot.I did a bit of digging around and came up with these guns.


1. Joseph Lang 12 gauge (Best Boxlock) Side by Side second hand Shotgun (R/H)

Barrel: 28", Stock: 143/4", Chokes: 1/2 & 3/4
Origin: English, Circa: 1950, Chamber: 2"3/4
Trigger: 2, Ejection: YES, Serial #: 19118 - Price: $4,313

2.Evans, William 12 gauge Boxlock ((From Purdey's)) Side by Side second hand Shotgun (X-Over)
Barrel: 28", Stock: 143/8", Chokes: 1/4 & 1/2, Weight: 6lb.8oz.
Origin: English, Chamber: 2"3/4
Trigger: 2, Ejection: YES, Serial #: 10411
Cast is from right to left and is 2 1/4" from the centre. The barrels were lined by Teague in Sept 2008. Some case hardening on the action. Drop at the heel is 2 1/2", Drop at the comb is 1 5/8".

Price: US$6,049

3. Webley & Scott 12 gauge 700 Side by Side second hand Shotgun (R/H)

Chokes: 1/4 & 1/2
Origin: English
Ejection: YES, Serial #: 145472
One of the last of 200 made with certificate from Webley and Scott in original and lovely condition.
Price: $3,601

5.Bate & Co., George (Birmingham) 12 gauge Boxlock Side by Side second hand Shotgun (R/H)
Barrel: 28", Stock: 141/2", Chokes: 3/8 & 5/8
Origin: English
Trigger: Double Trigger, Ejection: Ejector, Serial #: 15455
-Very good condition-virtually all colour remaining -Superb quality, fully rose & scroll engraved action -Raised ‘Churchill’ type rib -Bore sizes .734” & .733”
Price: $5,401


Now- check the price of the gun number 4.

4. Francotte 12 gauge Boxlock Side by Side second hand Shotgun (R/H)

Barrel: 28", Stock: 14", Chokes: 3/4 & Full, Weight: 6lb.8oz.
Origin: Belgian
Trigger: 2, Ejection: No, Serial #:
Lovely condition Auguste Francotte boxlock, with scoop-backed treble-grip action with side-clips, manual safety, broad turned rib, very detailed leaf engraved fences, border and scroll engraving, sling swivels and well figured original stock, with good sharp checkering and checkered butt. Reproved in 2008. Appears to have had very light use since manufacture in the 1930s. The 80000 series of Francotte guns signified their mid-range guns of the era. Lovely, lively gun.

Price: $857.

A tired and worn gun that has been given a breath of life by barrel lining costs the most of the lot at $6K just because it has William Evans name on it.Whereas the Auguste Francotte gun costs as little as $857 ?Agreed it is a non-ejector gun.But, it oozes quality and craftsmanship and certainly looks better than the William Evans gun.

My question.Am I being too simplistic/ignorant here or the rest of the guns are certainly better than the Francotte gun or is it just the quirk of the market that is sold on names?
I would really appreciate your inputs.Given a choice, I would certainly not hesitate to pick the Francotte gun first,closely followed by the Joseph Lang gun.

Thanks in advance for your replies.

@ Herb, The WE gun has a crossover stock for a left-eye dominant-right handed shooter.


Best-
Vikram

[.32]

Do I see a similar topic:

http://www.shotgunworld.com/bbs/viewtop ... istol+grip

[grewal]

Do I see a similar topic:

http://www.shotgunworld.com/bbs/viewtop ... istol+grip

Gurpreet Sandhu the Sherlock

[kanwar76]

Do I see a similar topic:

http://www.shotgunworld.com/bbs/viewtop ... istol+grip

Its not Similar, its same..started by the same guy at both forums

[grewal]

Its not Similar, its same..started by the same guy at both forums.

oh what a " startling revelation " made by kanwar, thanks for enlightening everyone on this forum

[kanwar76]

Its not Similar, its same..started by the same guy at both forums.

oh what a " startling revelation " made by kanwar, thanks for enlightening everyone on this forum

That was in response to your friend's "Do I see a similar topic"

And if you are really enlightened can you please let me know the reason of .32's post?

-Inder

[shooter]

I am assuming in the range of $2000-$6000.

Interesting stock on gun number 2 (William Evans), looks like cast for a right hand shooter with dominant left eye.

Herb

Spot on herb. Though it could also be for someone with central vision.

Though i would personally prefer other methods for cross eye dominace.
In todays times no one prefers cross over stock for eye dominance problems.

[Vikram]

Do I see a similar topic:

http://www.shotgunworld.com/bbs/viewtop ... istol+grip

Yes,you do.And your point is?

Best-
Vikram