Page 1 of 3

Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2019 10:25 pm
by pm40909
My query to all veterans-

Is .177 air rifle with 1200fps is more lethal or
.22 air rifle of 800fps.

Kindly throw light. Accuracy aspect be ignored.

Thanks

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 12:27 am
by Vikram
In the Indian context, only house rats are relevant to this question. Both will do the job on them. You may really want to think about this question.

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 12:56 am
by noblekumar
pm40909 wrote:My query to all veterans-

Is .177 air rifle with 1200fps is more lethal or
.22 air rifle of 800fps.

Kindly throw light. Accuracy aspect be ignored.

Thanks
The muzzle energy matters! Choose the right pellets for the job. Use this calculator to get some answers for your question https://www.pyramydair.com/airgun-resou ... Units&u=14

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 5:06 am
by pm40909
Thanks a lot. My query has been answered by your suggestion.

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 8:34 am
by Shivaji.Dasgupta
pm40909 wrote:My query to all veterans-

Is .177 air rifle with 1200fps is more lethal or
.22 air rifle of 800fps.

Kindly throw light. Accuracy aspect be ignored.

Thanks

Lethal ??????? .177 0r .22 ????

For a .177 0r .22 AR the Lethal word is only Relevant in context of Rodents irrespective of its Muzzle Energy. It may cause some harm or damage if it fired on a Human subject but I doubt that in any way it will reach to the point of Lethal definition ( May be some imported Weapon models have the Power to injure a Human target Seriously but it is again in Question)

and as rightly said by Vikram for Rodents any of the above mentioned variants will do their job.

Regards

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 11:20 am
by pm40909
Thanks everyone for the response. I put my query straight.
There has been lot of power appreciation about .22 Aarmr hurricane 18 model.

I have NX 100 & Diana 460 Magnum, but both in .177 calibre. Diana is superb in power & accuracy, breaks beer bottle at 20 metres using 8.3 grain pellets.

Having heard about Aarmr .22,. I just want to know does it have the same power,. ignoring the accuracy aspect.

Thanks, if someone can inform.

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 12:58 pm
by russianshooter3
Lethal only Air rifle in 6,35 mm 7,62mm and 9 mm
also now as hunting air rifle muzzle power more 25 J - Basic PCP air rifle

All air rifle sell in India its toy with power ~ 7 J may kill rat in house!

pm40909 with 177 (22) rifle may hunting to beer bottle :D :D :D :D :D

some foto for info lethal air bullet in 6,35 mm 7,62mm and 9 mm

if you need "lethal" air rifle in 177 - buy pcp air rifle,breakdown the moderator and kraft handmade pellets looks like bullet in 22lr
legal this in India or not i don t now
muzzle energy with this custom variant ~ 17-22 j

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 1:52 pm
by Chengy
Lethality is all about energy delivered on impact and type of target. Energy is basically about velocity and mass of the projectile. Type of target is about density of the material.

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 2:57 pm
by Shivaji.Dasgupta
pm40909 wrote:Thanks everyone for the response. I put my query straight.
There has been lot of power appreciation about .22 Aarmr hurricane 18 model.

I have NX 100 & Diana 460 Magnum, but both in .177 calibre. Diana is superb in power & accuracy, breaks beer bottle at 20 metres using 8.3 grain pellets.

Having heard about Aarmr .22,. I just want to know does it have the same power,. ignoring the accuracy aspect.

Thanks, if someone can inform.

yes you are right.. I have Aarmar Hurricane in .22 and its very powerful. I use the .22 rabbit shot gifted to me by one of my friend ( My Bad luck last 50/60 shots are left now) . At 25/30 Yrds it will instantly drop any vermin ( You need to Check the Pest control and wild Life Rules in your area Bro).
As per power Aarmar .22 is a good Air Rifle.
Vale for Money.
images (1).jpg
Sample Image.. :) :)

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 3:03 pm
by pm40909
Thanks Shivaji. But do we easily find aprop fitting pellets for Aarmr .22

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 3:10 pm
by pm40909
Also, Sir I am getting .22 Aarmr for Rs 16500/- in Dehradun and that too without bill. I feel he is charging considerably in excess.
Could you please advise on that.
Thanks

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 3:59 pm
by Vikram
pm40909 wrote:Also, Sir I am getting .22 Aarmr for Rs 16500/- in Dehradun and that too without bill. I feel he is charging considerably in excess.
Could you please advise on that.
Thanks
That is because a .22 air rifle is considered a firearm under the new rules and requires license to possess.The dealer is not only breaking the law, he is making a good profit on the deal. Remember, ignorance of law is no excuse in the court.

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 4:20 pm
by pm40909
Thanks.

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 8:12 pm
by Shivaji.Dasgupta
pm40909 wrote:Also, Sir I am getting .22 Aarmr for Rs 16500/- in Dehradun and that too without bill. I feel he is charging considerably in excess.
Could you please advise on that.
Thanks
Its on high side. Though I have seen the .22 is selling freely in Kanpur meerut and MP Towns but its against the law now. the price of the .22 is always under 10k.

Re: Which rifle has more lethality ?

Posted: Thu Jul 11, 2019 8:19 pm
by pm40909
Thanks, then I feel I should try to be contended with my .177 460 mag. Thanks Shivaji once again. Regards