I was reading about book The honest always stand alone, by C. G. Somiah IAS officer ex . It was interesting how an officer intervened to safe guard RKBA ..wish there were more of his ilk around.
I would like if some one could write something about Guns and their worship by Coorgs..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kodagu
http://www.ourkarnataka.com/Articles/st ... luck09.htm
"The Kodavas are a small community and it is estimated that the total population of Kodavas living in Coorg and also outside it, is not more than two lakh. This small number is distributed among 700 - odd family names."
Somiah comes from Kottoli village near Virajpet. Coorgs per se are known for their handsome personality and height. C. G. Somiah himself is a six - footer. They are also known for their honesty, fairness in dealings and courage even under adverse circumstances. Examples of this trait can be found in many places in the book. ....
It was the time when people from Kerala residing in Coorg and also in the neighbouring Kerala were demanding withdrawal of the concession granted to Kodavas under the Indian Arms Act to own guns without a licence.
The provocation for this unexpected demand was a stray incident of communal disharmony in Kodagu following a case of eve - teasing of a Coorg girl by a youth belonging to the Moplah community. This led to violence and arson. In the market area of Virajpet, a wayside temple was also desecrated. During the clashes that followed, two Moplahs died, one of them having suffered gunshot wounds. The situation was soon brought under control but a month later, the Home Ministry at the Centre received a surprise letter from the Chief Minister of Kerala, addressed to the Home Minister. The letter narrated the incident and suggested that the gun culture in Coorg had to be curbed by withdrawing the concession.
Here is what the Home Secretary C.G. Somiah writes in his book: "The Section dealing with the Arms Act was in charge of a Malayali Section Officer and he gleefully supported the proposal with endorsements from senior officers, when the file landed on my desk. In the Arms Act enacted by the British government in India, the Indian Princes and the Kodavas of Coorg owning jamma lands were both exempted from the provision of the Arms Act. Indira Gandhi, while abolishing the payment of Privy Purses to the Princes, also got the concession of exemption under the Arms Act enjoyed by them abolished. This fact was also mentioned in the letter of the Chief Minister of Kerala who wanted the similar exemption granted to Kodavas abolished.
"I recorded an appropriate note in the file explaining the rationale behind this concession granted to Kodavas in the first place and also the fact that possession of a gun [which is worshipped] is as sacred to the Kodava inhabitants of Coorg as it was sacred for a Sikh to possess a Kirpan [sword]. Buta Singh [Home Minister] readily agreed with me and a suitable reply was sent to the Chief Minister of Kerala. The age - old custom and the right of the Kodavas were thus safeguarded."
From Outlook India
http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?266450
"Somiah emerges as a deeply spiritual person, proud of his Kodava heritage. There is no pretended conflict of interest when he, as part of the home ministry, rejects the suggestion to ban the Kodava right to possess guns—he compares it with the right of the Sikhs to hold kirpans. Of course, he also wryly notes that the first time his community chose to honour him was when he had the word ‘general’ suffixed to his name as Comptroller and Auditor General of India !
Kodova and right to bear guns
-
- Old Timer
- Posts: 2973
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2006 7:28 pm
- Location: US
-
- Shooting true
- Posts: 633
- Joined: Tue Nov 04, 2008 11:29 am
- Location: Hyderabad
Re: Kodova and right to bear guns
I like the fact that the Kodavas can bear arms without a license , what about the rest of us poor turds , Do we have to be reborn as Kodavas to be able to get this privilege? Or is there a way to convert into a Kodava, from my current relegion/caste etc.
Please do not misunderstand, I have nothing against our Kodava or Sikh brothers, I am not asking that their rights be diluted, I am merely saying that having "classes" of people each with privileges of their own, will only fragment us further as a Nation. Saying that bearing arms "is part of their religion so they must be exempt" is a very poor mindset. If that is the attitude of the Government, then the word equality has no meaning under our Constitution. Every Citizen/Resident of India must be accorded the same rights/privileges.
Just look at the situation, among the existing Arms licensees itself we are now segregated into classes/sets where we have:
1.Prohibited bore licensees/Non prohibited bore licensees
2.Licensees with 3 firearms or less;
3.Licensees with 3 +1 firearms because of Rifle club memberships
4.Renowned shots who can own more than the above, up to 10 firearms
5.All India/State/District Licensees
6.Exempted categories such as Kodavas of Coorg
7.Members of Armed forces or Retd.
8.Serving bureaucrats
9.V VIP; VIP; IP (Film Star/Cricketer etc.)
10. And above all else some are actually exempted partially or completely from the Arms Laws of India
(I assume in the "interests of public safety" )
11.TR persons & renowned shots who can import
I am sure there are many others but these come to mind. So exactly what equality are we being guaranteed? Is this all necessary? Simply by better law enforcement and better background checks every person should be able to get An All India License with 10 firearms or bring the ordinary licensee to the level of super VIPs who are currently exempted from the Arms Law .
Regards,
Anand
Please do not misunderstand, I have nothing against our Kodava or Sikh brothers, I am not asking that their rights be diluted, I am merely saying that having "classes" of people each with privileges of their own, will only fragment us further as a Nation. Saying that bearing arms "is part of their religion so they must be exempt" is a very poor mindset. If that is the attitude of the Government, then the word equality has no meaning under our Constitution. Every Citizen/Resident of India must be accorded the same rights/privileges.
Just look at the situation, among the existing Arms licensees itself we are now segregated into classes/sets where we have:
1.Prohibited bore licensees/Non prohibited bore licensees
2.Licensees with 3 firearms or less;
3.Licensees with 3 +1 firearms because of Rifle club memberships
4.Renowned shots who can own more than the above, up to 10 firearms
5.All India/State/District Licensees
6.Exempted categories such as Kodavas of Coorg
7.Members of Armed forces or Retd.
8.Serving bureaucrats
9.V VIP; VIP; IP (Film Star/Cricketer etc.)
10. And above all else some are actually exempted partially or completely from the Arms Laws of India
(I assume in the "interests of public safety" )
11.TR persons & renowned shots who can import
I am sure there are many others but these come to mind. So exactly what equality are we being guaranteed? Is this all necessary? Simply by better law enforcement and better background checks every person should be able to get An All India License with 10 firearms or bring the ordinary licensee to the level of super VIPs who are currently exempted from the Arms Law .
Regards,
Anand
-
- Old Timer
- Posts: 2928
- Joined: Sun Dec 07, 2008 12:35 pm
Re: Kodova and right to bear guns
I fully agree everyone should have equal rights, self defense and RKBA are fundamental rights.Saying that bearing arms "is part of their religion so they must be exempt" is a very poor mindset. If that is the attitude of the Government, then the word equality has no meaning under our Constitution. Every Citizen/Resident of India must be accorded the same rights/privileges.
“Liberty has never come from Government. Liberty has always come from the subjects of it... The history of liberty is a history of limitations of governmental power, not the increase of it.” - Woodrow T. wilson
A people that values its privileges above its principles soon loses both. ~Dwight D. Eisenhower
"If my mother tongue is shaking the foundations of your State, it probably means that you built your State on my land" - Musa Anter, Kurdish writer, assassinated by the Turkish secret services in 1992
-
- Almost at nirvana
- Posts: 140
- Joined: Thu Feb 04, 2010 2:34 pm
- Location: hyderabad
- Contact:
Re: Kodova and right to bear guns
‘The world is filled with violence. Because criminals carry guns, we decent law-abiding citizens should also have guns. Otherwise they will win and the decent people will lose.’’
- shooter
- Old Timer
- Posts: 2002
- Joined: Tue May 22, 2007 8:55 pm
- Location: London
Re: Kodova and right to bear guns
Worship of arms is not unique to the kodavas.
I dont want to go into lists of castes etc but in general in the veds, there are entire passages that guide us about how to perform pooja of a particular weapon (yes different ones had different mantras).
The reasons for kodavas was that an IAS close to the ministry was from that caste.
Britishofficers have written about worship od arms in the non-kodavaregions.
Dashmi is the traditional day in general. In general in karnataka and other parts of the south it is still called as "ayudh pooja". Literally translated as worship of weapons.
Weapon worship still takes place in as north as nepal, as east as assam to as west as kutch and as southas kerela.
I agree with Anand, GBM and tonysilas.
I dont want to go into lists of castes etc but in general in the veds, there are entire passages that guide us about how to perform pooja of a particular weapon (yes different ones had different mantras).
The reasons for kodavas was that an IAS close to the ministry was from that caste.
Britishofficers have written about worship od arms in the non-kodavaregions.
Dashmi is the traditional day in general. In general in karnataka and other parts of the south it is still called as "ayudh pooja". Literally translated as worship of weapons.
Weapon worship still takes place in as north as nepal, as east as assam to as west as kutch and as southas kerela.
I agree with Anand, GBM and tonysilas.
You want more gun control? Use both hands!
God made man and God made woman, but Samuel Colt made them equal.
One does not hunt in order to kill; on the contrary, one kills in order to have hunted. by Jose Gasset.
God made man and God made woman, but Samuel Colt made them equal.
One does not hunt in order to kill; on the contrary, one kills in order to have hunted. by Jose Gasset.