What Mark is saying, in effect is; the whisky better have good 'legs' or 'tears' , while the gun oil should not!
![Wink ;)](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
I would go with Ed's red for cleaning and
'Mark's red' - ATF + kerosene oil or ATF + Acetone in a 1:1 for lubrication
Fauji oil has for me, varied from a thick viscous evil looking oil, to light green oil, very similar to 2T or gear box!
Maybe its what the unit armourer has in surplus that month?
I was taught to use boiling hot water to clean bores (corrosive primer/ cordite hangover?) and use a light oil for a minimal 'FILM' of oil. With better tech and products coming up, I would not be averse to trying the Gsmith product when I run out of my current stock of break free.